Cloth Diapers Diaper Covers Made in the USA Newborn Diapers Preemie Diapers PUL Sized Diapers Velcro/Aplix Closure

Thirsties Preemie/Newborn Cloth Diaper Cover vs. XS

@Thirstiesinc XS #clothdiapers cover vs new preemienewborn - via @chgdiapers

I received the newborn cover at no cost. Post contains affiliate links. I was not otherwise compensated for this post and all opinions are my own. As promised when I announced the new Thirsties products, today I’m comparing the XS sized cover to the brand new preemie/newborn cover.

@ThirstiesInc XS vs newborn #clothdiapers covers via @chgdiapers 1

I tried both the size 1 duo wrap and the XS cover on my 6.5 lb newborn in 2011. As I showed in my size 1 duo and XS cover comparison, the small size 1 duo setting is nearly identical to the XS cover.

@ThirstiesInc XS vs newborn #clothdiapers covers via @chgdiapers 2

Since the XS (pictured in green here – this one was purchased several years ago so it does not have the new H&L) fits babies from 6-12 pounds, some wondered why the newborn size (pictured in gray) was needed. I think the preemie newborn cover (fits 4-10 lbs) fills a much needed gap in the product line.

@ThirstiesInc XS vs newborn #clothdiapers covers via @chgdiapers 3 @ThirstiesInc XS vs newborn #clothdiapers covers via @chgdiapers 4

@ThirstiesInc XS vs newborn #clothdiapers covers via @chgdiapers 5 @ThirstiesInc XS vs newborn #clothdiapers covers via @chgdiapers 6 size 1 duo on bottom

Above I’ve also pictured the size 1 duo in yellow. The preemie/newborn cover is smaller and narrower overall. The differences are subtle but I think it would have been a much better fit on my tiny guy.

@ThirstiesInc XS vs newborn #clothdiapers covers via @chgdiapers 7 with rumpzrooz newborn @ThirstiesInc XS vs newborn #clothdiapers covers via @chgdiapers 8 vs rumparooz newborn

The Rumparooz newborn cover is another teeny cover (though the RAR has rise snaps and fits 4-12 lbs). The Thirsties is narrower/trimmer.

Below is the Thirsties preemie/newborn compared to a preemie disposable diaper. (P.S. yes, it’s the same bear – he’s just been extremely well loved in the past 5ish years!)

preemie front @ThirstiesInc preemie newborn #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers

The XS vs. a newborn disposable:

newborn front @Thirstiesinc xs #clothdiapers cover

My son at about 6.5 lbs in the XS cover, with a hemp insert inside:

@Thirstiesinc xs #clothdiapers cover on 6.5 lb baby

Even though my son was in the XS size range, I think the preemie/newborn cover would have fit him much better in the early days when he was really tiny and I was trying to keep diapers under his cord stump. Both sizes have an MSRP of $12 and the preemie/newborn is only available in hook & loop closures. The XS is available in hook & loop (both sizes have a smaller 1″ hook & loop vs the 1 1/2″ of the larger sizes) and snap closures.

Have you tried the XS covers? Would you like to try the preemie/newborn?

Share on Pinterest
Maria Moser
Maria is the mother of 3, writing about cloth diapers & going green. You'll often find her with a dog or child on her lap, typing 1-handed in between sips of cold coffee. Maria works with many companies within the cloth diaper industry and beyond, providing social media management, product development, and other services.

Leave Your Comment

Your Comment*

Your Name*
Your Webpage