Cloth Diapers Fitted Diapers Made in the USA Natural Fiber Diapers One Size Diapers

Orange Diaper Co vs Sustainablebabyish Bamboo Fitted Cloth Diapers

Orange Diaper Co vs Sbish Snapless os bamboo #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 0

I recently posted an Orange Diaper Co review as well as a Sustainablebabyish review, and some of you were wondering how they compare.

Orange Diaper Co vs Sbish Snapless os bamboo #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 1

I will not repeat all the info about each diaper; please read the reviews for all the nitty gritty. This post is simply to point out differences!

Orange Diaper Co vs Sbish Snapless os bamboo #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 2 leg elastic Orange Diaper Co vs Sbish Snapless os bamboo #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 4 waist

Both have serged edges at the waist elastic, but the Sbish has turned & topstitched leg elastic.

Orange Diaper Co vs Sbish Snapless os bamboo #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 3 overall Orange Diaper Co vs Sbish Snapless os bamboo #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 5 wings
Orange Diaper Co vs Sbish Snapless os bamboo #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 6 fronts

Both have nice, long wings, though the diapers have a slightly different shape.

Orange Diaper Co vs Sbish Snapless os bamboo #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 12 folded Orange Diaper Co vs Sbish Snapless os bamboo #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 13 stretched

The ODC is larger overall, though the Sbish stretches to nearly the same size.

Orange Diaper Co vs Sbish Snapless os bamboo #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 8 thickness Orange Diaper Co vs Sbish Snapless os bamboo #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 9 width through middle

The Sbish does seem to be cut a bit trimmer through the middle.

Orange Diaper Co vs Sbish Snapless os bamboo #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 7 soakers

The Sbish comes with two, 3-layer, lay in soakers, while the ODC has a single, 4-layer bamboo-terry soaker, that snaps in, and is sewn in layers for faster drying. It is essentially the same length as the diaper, and can easily be doubled over in the wet zone.

Orange Diaper Co Bamboo Fitted #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 18 @sloomb #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 20

Both worked well with Boingos and Snappis.

Orange Diaper Co Bamboo Fitted #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 14 @sloomb #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 22

Both diapers are pictured on my son at the same age/weight (around 9.5 months and 16 lbs.) Both fit with lots of room to grow.

Orange Diaper Co vs Sbish Snapless os bamboo #clothdiapers via @chgdiapers 10 close up

I haven’t done any pseudo-scientific absorbency testing, but both were plenty absorbent for extended daytime use for us. Each has its own features, so if you’re trying to choose, decide what cut/shape and what soaker style you prefer most!

Both diapers were received at no cost for review purposes. All opinions are solely mine.


Share on Pinterest
 
Maria Moser
Maria is the mother of 3, writing about cloth diapers & going green. You'll often find her juggling her preschooler and typing 1-handed in between sips of cold coffee. Maria works with many companies within the cloth diaper industry and beyond, providing social media management, product development and other services.
6 Comments
  • Jay
    October 17, 2012 at 6:49 pm
    Reply

    The comparison photos were great. Have you ever tried either one overnight? If so , how did they perform?

    • October 17, 2012 at 6:58 pm
      Reply

      I haven’t tried either at night, but perhaps if I do a water absorbency comparison to my current night time solution, I’d feel comfortable trying them at night. If I do, I will update! I believe that Sbish makes a different fitted that is designed for night time.

      • Jay
        October 19, 2012 at 4:32 pm
        Reply

        Have you shared your nighttime solution before in a previous post? What is it?

        • October 19, 2012 at 5:09 pm
          Reply

          Things I’ve tried at night are super absorbent (rather bulky) fitteds with wool over top, and Knickernappies Superdo inserts, which were great…but got stinky and required bleaching, which eventually broke down the hemp. Right now I use a M/L (lavender edge) Geffen Baby hemp prefold in a pocket and I love it. I do work for the company (but I love the products!!) so I want to make sure I’ve disclosed that, but it is working great for us, and lots of other moms too!

  • Regina
    October 17, 2012 at 1:45 pm
    Reply

    I’ve been a ODC lover since they were scuttlebutts so I’m totally biased. Thanks for the review

  • Rebecca Orr
    October 16, 2012 at 11:33 am
    Reply

    Thanks!!

Leave Your Comment

Your Comment*

Your Name*
Your Webpage